Showing posts with label Obama. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Obama. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 2, 2010

Stiglitz: Obama's Falling Down on the Job

Joseph Stiglitz recently published an article in the New York Daily News, giving some credit to the President's handling of the economy, but remaining highly critical.

He cites three main failings:
  1. "They underestimated the severity of the downturn. As a result, the stimulus program was too small"
  2. "The mortgage restructuring program was not well-designed: It allowed no write-down of principal, so it did little about the one quarter of mortgages where homeowners owe more than the value of their house"
  3. "The bank bailouts didn't do what they were supposed to: restart lending... while 140 smaller banks were allowed to fail, billions were poured into the big banks, who poured much of the money out in dividends and bonuses."
What we talked about in class today was very relevant to this and other posts I have made the past few days. The government continues to go through the subsidiary of the private financial institutions to reinvest in the economy, yet the these institutions have yet to do so. Meanwhile, firms are unable to hire new employees, who are then unable to purchase goods, or even pay off the debts they owe. To some extent, channeling government money to direct loans to reinvigorate businesses looking to expand the scope of their enterprise (specifically: jobs) would undercut the bailout money already provided to the banks with the same goal. However, as we have just given the bailout money with little stipulation as to its use, the banks don't seem about to act anyway.

I believe that most of you (liberal, conservative, and libertarian alike) would agree that continued government grants to the financial giants is ultimately self-destructive, given our spiraling national debt and the irresponsibility of the private institutions. In my last post, Evan argued for government investment in small banks, given "careful auditing" (which I interpret as ensuring it not go to massive bonuses or executive comfort), would let the profit motive will drive the most efficient use of money in the quickest amount of time. Though I moderately support the expansion of the SBA, at least in conjunction with support to small banks, I have significant doubts that small banks would act much differently lending-wise than the bigger, more secure banks.

What does the expanded circular flow model mean in regard to the recession and the stimulus? If we rely on the financial institutions to be the kick start to the economy, and they refrain from doing so, where do we go next?

Monday, February 1, 2010

The Plight of Small Businesses

The President stopped in Tampa, Florida in late January to give a speech and converse with citizens, the full-text of which can be found here

The majority of this is irrelevant, but someone online pointed out an interesting exchange between the President and a small business owner:

Q: My name is Steve Gordon. I'm from Clearwater. And I manufacture -- I own a small company, environmental company. I manufacture the Instant-Off water-saving device that fits on any faucet worldwide. I'm frustrated because I can create 500 jobs; I've gone to the banks, I can't get a loan. And I speak for all businesses in the United States. (Applause.) We are tired of dealing with banks. And I don't understand -- and this is my question for you, is that I know you care, I know you're trying. And I appreciate the pledge of $30 billion to small businesses. But lending it to the banks to lend to us is not the answer. It's just not.

What I suggest, and the question is, why can't you use the SBA just like you lent directly to Wall Street, you lent directly to the automakers, you lent directly to the banks -- why can't the government make small businesses available directly to us? (Applause.)

President Obama: [after his first response about success he sees so far, and an acknowledgement that Mr. Gordon may not see it as enough, the President continues] Keep in mind, a small business loan of any sort, or a large business loan of any sort requires some sense of, all right, what's the business plan, what are your projected earnings, et cetera, et cetera. And somebody has got to do that. Now, if the SBA were to suddenly take over that entire function we'd have to stand up a massive bureaucracy -- a huge one. And we'd have to train all those people and it would take too long, and you'd be frustrated -- why is it that this big government agency can't seem to run anything?

So what we've decided to do instead is to take $30 billion that was repaid by the banks and make that available under criteria that will encourage small banks to give those loans to you. And if we do that effectively, we can potentially get that money out the door more quickly.

Clearly, Obama is exactly the Socialist-bogeyman the Right has made him out to be, up there alongside the likes of Ronald Reagan, a notorious Communist-sympathizer.

I do understand where he's coming from. An expansion of the duties of the SBA, or any other government agency, would take time and money to set up. Obama believes that private enterprise, given government money with "encouragement" to lend, can respond more quickly and more efficiently. However, this ignores the role many of these very same enterprises had in the crisis, as well as the significant absence of reinvestment in the economy with the money received thus far.

I would argue that it could be useful to allocate at least some of the $30 billion to expand the scope of the SBA, to directly lend money to promising small businesses. This could run the danger of undercutting local banks, but something needs to change. As we've learned in class, the market's main characteristic is efficiency, efficiency of profitable return. A less profit-focused government agency might make funds available to proposals that are less efficient from a profit sense, but useful for the economy as a while and other reasons.

There is an immense interplay between government, banks, and business owners. What role do you believe is most appropriate and helpful for each actor? What are your thoughts in general?