Saturday, March 6, 2010

A Cover Ad That Mimics a Newspaper’s Front Page


The entire first page of The Los Angeles Times on Friday was an ad that looked, in part, like the front page of The Los Angeles Times, as the newspaper again tested the accepted limits on where ads can be published and how they can blur the boundary with news.

Enlarge This Image

The wrap-around ad on The Los Angeles Times on Friday. The simulated page shows articles that ran recently in the paper.
A garishly multicolored image of Johnny Depp as the Mad Hatter, in the film “Alice in Wonderland,” occupies most of the paper’s cover page, superimposed over what looks like the usual, sober front page. Above him is the “Los Angeles Times” banner, and bracketing his face are actual, recent articles.

The top editor of The Times, Russ Stanton, and several of his deputies vigorously opposed the ad before it was published, but they were overruled by the paper’s business executives, according to people with direct knowledge of the dispute, who were granted anonymity to discuss private conversations.

Mr. Stanton said only, “Obviously, it was not my decision.”

John Conroy, a spokesman for The Times, said, “Stretching the boundaries was what we were going for.” He said Eddy W. Hartenstein, the publisher and chief executive, and other executives would not comment.

Ads that completely cover a publication’s front page, or are made to look like part of it — or both — are not unusual for trade magazines and some tabloid newspapers, but broadsheets have generally shunned them. But Mr. Conroy noted that however unorthodox the ad may be for print, it mirrors a common practice online of having an ad cover part or all of a Web site’s home page for a few seconds.

“It’s taking a concept that we normally apply to new media and reimagining it to a concept in a newspaper,” he said.

Traditional limits on advertising have relaxed across the industry as newspapers struggle to cope with steep ad declines. In the last few years, The Los Angeles Times, The New York Times and The Wall Street Journal all began publishing ads on the lower parts of their front pages.

But The Los Angeles Times has gone several steps further. In April, it published a front-page ad for the TV series “Southland” that was made to look like a news article, prompting harsh criticism from media critics and its own journalists. Two months later, it published its first full front-page wrap-around ad, for the series “True Blood.”

The “Alice in Wonderland” ad, which also wraps around the paper, introduces a new wrinkle, lending the name and work of The Times to an advertiser.

For that reason, some Times journalists said they found it more troubling than the previous ads. But in general, it drew a more muted reaction in the newsroom than the “Southland” ad did, and some of the people interviewed noted that the paper received several hundred thousand dollars for such an ad.

“People are worried about what it does with the brand, the paper’s name,” said one reporter who, like his colleagues, insisted on anonymity to speak critically of his employer. “On the other hand, it’s money that we badly need.”

Geneva Overholser, director of the Annenberg School for Communication and Journalism at the University of Southern California, said the new ad was “not quite as clearly offensive” as the “Southland” ad, “because nobody could be fooled into thinking this was real editorial content.”

“It’s a little troubling that they’re blending editorial content with advertising,” she said. “This isn’t newspapering as it used to be, but that can’t be the determinant any more.”

Friday, March 5, 2010

An American Revolution

As we all know, two of the "Big Three" were bailed out last year amidst the financial crisis. However, we have recently seen the auto market go through some big changes because of the bailouts, recalls, and hard economic times. There is however, a bit of good news for Michigan, because General Motors has recently announced that "it would it planned to reinstate 661 dealers that it cut last year as part of its bankruptcy reorganization". This could be seen as a result of the volatile car market and the massive Toyota recalls. The New York Times reports that:

According to Jim Bunnell, GM's general director of dealer network support, "By doing this, we save a lot of time, energy and dollars, saving us and dealers from going through what could be a very long arbitration process". This is also a result of a relaunch of better selling cars, and a regaining of lost market shares. Furthermore, because of GM's and Ford's resurgence, and Toyota loss in market share, our imports have decreased, and our exports have increased, meaning our trade deficit has also decreased.

As we have discussed in class in regards to imports and exports, the Obama Administration's plan to grow out the GDP is slowly happening with the help of, "G.M., which is 60 percent owned by the Treasury Department as a result of the $50 billion in emergency loans that it received". This should also be good for taxpayers, because it appears as though GM will be paying back its debt quickly as well. GM's and Ford's recovery is hope for all companies that were affected by the financial crisis, because it shows that the American economy is recovery and more of our exports are being demanded. However, this new demands is also the result from a weak dollar, the stimulus plan, and "Cash for Clunkers" program.

What does this mean for Michigan? How do you think GM has done on its road to recovery? Is the recent revolution of the American car industry a result of market share losses by Toyota? How has this change in the economy been influenced by the Obama Administrations economic decisions? What does this mean for the trade deficit? Are we seeing a resurgent American economy?

Markets Get a Lift From Latest Jobs Report

Shares opened higher on Friday after the government’s employment report showed fewer jobs were cut in February than expected.

The Labor Department’s monthly report is widely seen as the most important economic indicator because employment is considered a crucial ingredient for a strong, sustained recovery.

Employers cut 36,000 jobs last month, better than forecasts of as much as 68,000 cuts. The unemployment rate held steady at 9.7 percent; economists were expecting it to rise to 9.8 percent.

In Europe, markets rose after a successful bond sale by debt-burdened Greece and the release of the American jobs report. Budget and debt problems in Greece have dogged the markets in recent months.

The higher open on top of a late-day rally in stocks Thursday indicates that investors are optimistic the United States economy is improving. Though employers are not yet adding staff full-time, jobs growth is fundamental to a recovery because it puts money in more workers pockets, allowing them to increase spending. Consumer spending accounts for about 70 percent of economic activity.

In early trading, the Dow Jones industrial average was 74.90 points, or 0.72 percent, higher. Standard & Poor’s 500-stock index rose 9.69 points, or 0.86 percent, while the Nasdaq rose 21.32 points, or 0.93 percent.

In London, the FTSE 100 rose 1.3 percent, the DAX in Frankfurt gained 1.1 percent, and the CAC-40 in Paris rose 1.8 percent. In Tokyo, Nikkei stock average surged 2.2 percent.

Signs of future jobs growth were encouraging in the report. Temporary workers, which are often seen as a precursor to employers adding full-time staff, rose 48,000 last month. Average hourly earnings rose by 3 cents to $22.46.

The Labor Department did not quantify if severe snowstorms that pummeled the East Coast last month had any impact on the report. Economists estimated before the report that the storms could inflate job losses by 100,000 or more.

Major indexes advanced Thursday, thanks to a late-day rally heading into the monthly jobs report. Other economic reports continued to paint a mixed picture for the economy.

Retailers reported surprisingly strong retail sales for February, led by companies like Abercrombie & Fitch, Nordstrom and the Target Corporation. Wal-Mart Stores raised its dividend 11 percent.

Meanwhile, bond prices fell. The yield on the benchmark 10-year Treasury note, which moves opposite its price, rose to 3.66 percent from 3.61 percent late Thursday.

The dollar rose against other major currencies after the jobs report. Gold fell slightly.

Thursday, March 4, 2010

Boosting GDP in Zero-G

The Obama administration is set to enact and observe a dramatic reshaping of the country's space program. The task of replacing the shuttle program is being left to private companies, and the coming years are expected to see a general privatization of space travel. Moreover, NASA's priorities are being reset with a renewed emphasis on scientific usefulness. Ultimately, I feel that the innovations in NASA, and in the field of Space Exploration in general, are set to provide real and substantial economic benefits, both to the world as a whole and to the U.S economy in particular.

The plan for replacing the space shuttles to provide government money to pay for private corporations, like Boeing and Space X, to provide the new launch vehicles to carry people and equipment into space. In paying for private companies to build the launch vehicles, the government stands to enter a situation wherein "everyone wins", ranging from the companies receiving the contracts, to the U.S taxpayers, who benefit from the new methods increased efficiency over previous projects, to other private corporations, which are also able to use the new launch vehicles.

The new launch vehicles will inherently be more economically efficient than the space shuttles, as (counter-intuitive as this sounds) they will not be reusable, and will thus not require expensive upkeep and repair work. The way that the Obama administration plans to pay for the shuttles will save taxpayer money as well. Previously, government aerospace contracts with private companies were payed on a "cost-plus" basis. What this means is that the government would award aerospace contracts to private companies, and would receive an estimate of the cost, but would only after the contract was completed find out what it would actually end up paying the company. The old system would thus leave little incentive for the contracted companies to keep down costs, and ultimately bred inefficiency and waste at the taxpayers expense. What the Obama Administration plans to do is to award contracts under a "fixed-contract" agreement, which awards contracts to companies under the understanding that the company will be paid an initially agreed upon amount. This leaves the companies, rather than the government, set to lose money if the project is over-budget, and thus creates an inventive for efficiency lacking under the cost-plus system.

In addition to saving taxpayer money (which could, say, help reduce our enormous budget deficit) the reworked approach towards space travel holds the promise of boosting GDP and the economy, both in the short and long term. By contracting private companies to provide launch vehicles, the Obama administration will be boosting the government spending (G) portion of GDP, and the multiplier effect will no doubt work to boost the economy to a level disproportionate with government spending. Moreover, as previously mentioned, by paying for the development of new launch vehicles, the Obama administration leaves private companies interested in sending people into orbit with a means to do so, which promises to facilitate the boosting of another segment of GDP, investment. A perfect example is, Bigelow Aerospace, which has invested hundreds of millions of dollars in a type of inflatable space-habitat, which it hopes to put into space and make available for scientific research. A new, privately supplied launch vehicle developed with government assistance would allow companies like Bigelow a relatively easy and inexpensive method by which to transport crew to these habitats.

As I interpret it, The Obama administrations approach to space travel/exploration thus promises to simultaneously save taxpayer money and boost GDP. What are your opinions on Obama's plans for the U.S space program? Here are some links to an article and a video that I used.

http://www.economist.com/science-technology/displaystory.cfm?story_id=15450607

http://audiovideo.economist.com/?fr_story=8d126c37ba95fd99da0ea66da7b905848063f803&rf=bm

Iceland! The Democracy of Debt

As the world focus' upon Europe's next move in terms of a bailout, the long forgotten, but first in trouble Iceland is voting on what it's first step will be on the road to recovery. As we have discussed in class, the Greeks are in need of a bailout by most likely Germany, and it doesn't have the means to grow out of it's debt. This is a similar case for other countries such as Portugal, Spain, and Ireland. However, what is interesting, is that although the European Union struggles to determine what route to take, Iceland is trying to get into the EU even when it's economy is in shambles from bankruptcy.

The Economist states: "ON MARCH 6TH Icelanders go to the polls to vote in an historic referendum. They must decide whether to accept or reject a deal made by their government to repay to the British and Dutch authorities €3.9 billion ($5.3 billion) lost by British and Dutch savers in Landsbanki, a failed Icelandic bank".

This deal provides that Iceland repay back it's debts to British and Dutch investors because as the two nations think, "Icelanders were happy to enjoy the fruits of the boom years, and should not try to wriggle out of the consequences now that their country’s enormous financial bubble has burst". However, Icelanders think that because they have to endure the losses, then so should the British and Dutch investors.

The problem lies in the fact that if the Icelanders vote no, a stance in which polls show about 70% of people support, then the already weak Krona would inflate and the IMF would probably no longer help them financially. Britain and the Netherlands have also threatened to block admission into the EU in the case of a no vote. However, because Iceland has only 320,000 people, it's already massive debt would take them decades to pay off, and also become a risky investment for more loans given to them. " The Landsbanki debts alone amount to over €12,000 for each of the country’s 320,000 citizens; total debts are approaching 1,000% of GDP", meaning that it is wild to think that Britain and the Netherlands would push so hard for this money when they would see the disadvantages for a weak economy in Iceland if they were to join the EU. Would this not just be another Greece waiting to be bailed out by Germany?

This is a difficult situation for the EU and Iceland, and it's impact could influence the decisions made in the EU nations that are near bankruptcy. Therefore, what do you think Iceland should do and why? What does a yes or no decision mean for the EU? In a time when the financial system in Europe is already strained, then why should Iceland be permitted to enter into the Euro-zone? Do you think it is wise for Iceland to join the EU? What does this mean for the EU nations wishing to be bailed out, and what does it mean for the nations such as Germany and France, who will front the money for the bailouts?

More Credit Card Reform?

I found this brief from the NPR financial blog, which states that a new Fed proposal is very clear about limiting credit card fees, but incredibly vague about lowering interest rates. With fees
The rules would limit fees for late payments and for exceeding a card's credit limit. Basically, the fee couldn't be higher than the value of the violation. For example, the fee for failing to make a minimum payment of $20 couldn't be more than $20.
This is great. I'm sure there are people who apply for a credit card to get a discount for a small item, forget they have the card or forget to pay it off, and eventually this one time late payment balloons with fees to be three times whatever was originally on the card. It also bans inactivity fees, fees put on the card as a penalty for the consumer not using it. This compounds the issue, lets say you paid off the balance of the store credit card and kept it for the sake of a good credit score and emergencies. You later find a bill from them stating that you are late on a payment on that supposedly zeroed out card, and must pay another fee. The credit card put an inactivity fee on your bill, then waited a month for you to no pay it so that they could charge you another fee. Up until February of this year it was legal, but unscrupulous and, since credit card companies make a lot of money off of fees, a favored way of maximizing income. The Fed announcement is part of their new position under that law.

The other way that Credit card companies get money is through charging interest on balances not paid in full. Lately their reaction to the declining economy is to raise their interests rates, which is some ways a gamble as they are expecting their customers to pay back their balance, plus that newly risen interest, without going bankrupt or shuffling their debt into another, less costly account. High credit card interest rates are bad for consumers.Who wants to spend money when you're facing an ever increasing pile of debt? The Fed wants people to spend again, and states:that it will:
  • Require credit card issuers to inform consumers of the reasons for increases in rates.
  • Require issuers that have increased rates since January 1, 2009 to evaluate whether the reasons for the increase have changed and, if appropriate, to reduce the rate.
Receiving an explanation for the increase in your credit card rate is all fine and dandy, granted it may be something along the lines of: "Our profits aren't increasing. The economy sucks and we need more income. Nothing personal" (albeit in fancier words with a reminder that they value your continued business). The other part, the more important part that would actually lower credit card rates, includes the words "if appropriate" before "reduce the rate." According to NPR, this raises the question:
"Who decides if it's appropriate?"
If the companies are expected to police themselves after they have been cut off from the revenue generated from hidden fees, I doubt it will be effective in any way shape or form. But the question remains: Who should determine the circumstances of a rate reduction?

An Explosion of Mobile Patent Lawsuits

Still something about patent...


At first glance, it looks like we’re in the middle of a patent lawsuit Super Bowl party. Nearly every large mobile phone player–with the exception of Microsoft and Palm — and, so far, Google, have recently been involved in some sort of patent litigation around their mobile technologies.

The graphic above shows a range of these lawsuits, which can be almost dizzying to look at and decipher. Within the last year, for example, Apple was sued by the Taiwanese company Elan Microelectronics, allegedly infringing on its touch screen patents. Nokia also went on a lawsuit spree, suing Apple, Samsung, LG and a variety of other mobile handset companies. Kodak sued a number of companies over patents related to the companies’ digital-imaging technology. And of course yesterday, Apple sued HTC, the Taiwanese handset maker.

Although patent litigation is not new in the technology world, these suits, specifically around mobile, point to the drastically changing mobile landscape. Lawyers I spoke with explained that mobile technology is still in its infancy and these large computing companies are trying to stake their claim to the future of computing.

On Tuesday when I spoke with Eric Von Hippel, a professor of technological innovation at M.I.T.’s Sloan School of Management, he pointed out that patent lawsuits have turned particular unpleasant lately as a result of companies that only buy and sell patents.

In the past, Mr. Von Hippel explained, if companies entered a litigious dispute “they would usually come to an agreement to simply share each other’s patents.” Mr. Von Hippel said that now, a new genre of patent lawsuits, brought on by what he calls “patent trolls,” changes the nature of the disputes. These companies have no interest in using the patents, but instead hope to reap large sums of money from the lawsuits.

Wednesday, March 3, 2010

Venzuela's Currency Devaluation

Reading chapter five on the components of GDP, I can't help but think about an article that I read in the Economist back in January, which talked about the effects of a drastic devaluation in the Venezuelan currency.

"OFFICIALLY it is an “exchange-rate adjustment” to make the country more competitive. But Venezuelans have been here before, and they know what to do. Within hours of a presidential decree on January 8th devaluing the currency by up to 50%, long queues formed outside household-appliance shops in Caracas, the capital. The minority with a little spare cash wanted to swap it as fast as possible for something of more durable value."


I think that this was effectively a case of the government sacrificing long-term GDP growth for short-term economic benefits. The article speculated that the devaluation may have been conducted in order to leave Venezuelan president Hugo Chavez to reverse recent government spending cuts (caused by a decrease in oil revenues, Valenzuela's predominant export and source of 90% of the country's hard currency). By devaluing the currency, the Venezuelan government turned a 6-8% budget deficit into a budget surplus, and the government was allowed to increase government spending once again.

However, while an increase in government spending, the "G" component of GDP, and the temporary surge in consumer spending no doubt helped to boost GDP an perceived economic well-being in the short-run, I'd like to see the long terms effects that inflation had on the economy. Inflation, by reducing the value of money, effectively reduces the incentive to hold and save money. While this caused the temporary boost in consumer spending spoken of in the article, it would have drastically reduced another, critical portion of Venezuela's GDP, investment (I); an area of GDP already discouraged by, as the article put it, "Mr Chávez’s price controls, punitive regulation and threats of expropriation...". Moreover, as the article also mentioned, government harassment of business owners would likely have prevented exports from benefiting from a devalued currency (as is the case with China) and left Venezuela as reliant upon oil exports as ever. And as oil prices are down, this would leave another portion of Venezuela's GDP, the net exports (NX) with little or no boost.

I'm thus of the opinion that if the Venzuelan governments devaluation of its currency hasn't contributed to lower GDP by now, it almost surely will in the future. What are your thoughts on the matter? Devaluation of a nation's currency was, after all, one of the options for eliminating national debt. Would devaluing our currency like Hugo Chavez devalued Venezuela's be a good idea?

Facebook Ads Strike Some as Off-Key

SAN FRANCISCO — Facebook, the world’s biggest social network, is selling more ad spots to big companies like Wal-Mart Stores, Procter & Gamble and PepsiCo.

But the site’s pages are also home to countless ads from smaller companies that can be funny, weird or just plain creepy — those suggesting you are, say, eligible to get a free iPad because you are exactly 26 years old, or entreaties to see what your offspring would look like if you had a child with a celebrity.

Odd Web ads, like the dancing women promoting mortgage brokers, are not new. But on social networks like Facebook, where people go to communicate with one another, advertisers seem to be trying especially hard to intrude on the conversation.

The so-called self-service ads on the site, from the likes of video game start-ups, herbal supplement makers, sweepstakes companies and wedding photographers, are shown on the right side of most pages. Many advertisers who use the self-service system are tempted to go as far as possible in making ads that attract attention and appear relevant, aided by the information that people give to Facebook.

“When it works, it’s amazingly impactful, but when it doesn’t work, it’s not only creepy but off-putting,” said Tim Hanlon, a principal at the consulting firm Riverview Lane Associates of Chicago. “What a marketer might think is endearing, by knowing a little bit about you, actually crosses the line pretty easily.”

One campaign that flooded the site in recent weeks, before Facebook cracked down on it, tries to take advantage of consumer interest in Apple’s iPad. “Are you a fan of Eddie Izzard? We need 100 music and movie lovers to test and KEEP the new Apple iPad,” one version of the ad says. Louis Allred Jr., 29, a Facebook user in Los Angeles who saw the ad, said he figured it was shown to him because he or a friend had expressed enthusiasm for Mr. Izzard, a British comedian, on their profiles.

“It doesn’t seem like they are using the information in sensible ways,” Mr. Allred said.

Mr. Allred was also skeptical about the test-an-iPad offer. The ad sends people to Prize-Rewards.net, a site that appears to be based in Vancouver, Canada, and tries to get people to pursue rewards by signing up for memberships in services like Netflix. Efforts to reach the company were unsuccessful.

Dan Rose, vice president for business development at Facebook, compared the company’s self-service ad platform to the early versions of Google’s highly profitable AdWords system. He predicted that the quality of the promotional messages on the site would improve as more companies began to use it.

“A year ago, we had lower-quality ads, and a year from now we will have higher-quality ads,” Mr. Rose said. “It’s early, but we have made a lot of progress.”

The self-service ad system offers any person or company the opportunity to quickly design an ad and aim it toward finely segmented groups of Facebook’s 400 million members, based on gender, age, location and preferences like favorite movies and activities.

For example, a promoter can advertise tickets to a band’s concert to the select group of Facebook users who live in the area and have mentioned that band on their profile page or status updates. Or a wedding photographer can show ads only to people in a certain city who have switched their relationship status to “engaged.”

“I’ve had good success with it on a limited budget,” said Carter Rose, a wedding photographer in Dallas who has paid $1,700 for Facebook ads over the last few months and as a result booked three weddings at $3,500 each.

Many advertisers view a site like Facebook as a good place for playful messages. Cordarounds, a San Francisco pants company, talks about “pigeon matadors” and “trouserbots” that make pants in a “zero-G environment” to capture attention for its products on Facebook.

“It’s a conversational medium. If you can be the originator of that conversation, you are fitting in,” said Chris Lindland, the company’s chief executive, who uses Facebook to advertise solely to young men in the 20 largest urban areas.

From the perspective of many users, the tailored ads can often seem, at best, presumptuous.

Women who change their status to “engaged” on Facebook to share the news with their friends, for example, report seeing a flood of advertisements for services and products like wedding photographers, skin treatments and weight-loss regimens.

Then there are the nonsensical ads, which highlight the fact that Facebook does not have employees to review each ad, but relies largely on member feedback to flag inappropriate messages. That allows ads to slip through that run afoul of the company’s policies. “Laws now allow U.S. residents to reduce their credit card debt by more than 50 percent,” reads one ad for a debt-relief Web site, which is accompanied by a surreal image of four tiny babies lying in the palm of a hand.

“It caught my eye, but it sure didn’t win my trust,” said Paige Kobert, 32, an advertising employee from San Francisco who saw the ad recently. “It just seemed like a scam.”

A Facebook spokesman, Brandon McCormick, said ads like that one and the Eddie Izzard iPad ad violated a Facebook policy that requires the text and photo in the ad to be related to what is being advertised.

Mr. McCormick said that in the last few weeks, Facebook had begun enforcing that provision after users complained about the flood of ads aimed at alumni from a certain university or people of a certain age (“Hey, 32-Year-Olds”), with messages that had nothing to do with those characteristics.

Such ads are the equivalent of a direct mail “special offer for John Smith” that turns out to be not so special.

Facebook users seem most perplexed when they are left wondering why they have received a customized ad.

Jess Walker, 22, from central Florida, was recently presented an ad for Plan B, the morning-after pill.

“What do I have on my Facebook page that would lead them to believe I would need that?” she asked, adding that she did not want her sexual behavior called into question.

Ms. Walker noted that Facebook allowed her to delete the ad from the page she was viewing. — which would then make Facebook less likely to allow that particular ad to be sent to other people.

Mr. Rose from Facebook said the ads on the site were becoming more professional and straightforward as the company updated its policies and enforced them.

“When you have got the platform that we have, you are naturally going to attract people who are going to game it,” Mr. Rose said.

Haiti, Tariffs, and the Catch Up Theory

I was listening to NPR today and found this story: What Haiti Needs More Than Charity: Trade It follows representatives from Haiti's garment industry as they vie for greater US trade through a no Tariff system. Currently they have no tariffs, but only for a certain amount of exports
Right now, the Gap, Levi's and some others do buy clothes made in Haiti. But there are a bunch of others who don't, because of the quota on how many clothes Haiti can export to the U.S. without having to pay tariffs — including some big players, such as J.C. Penney and Wal-Mart.
Essentially, these Haitian businessmen are arguing for a form of catch-up: The U.S lessens or loses its Haitian trade quota's, the Haitians are able to make and export more shirts, they employ more people and the whole country's economy improves. On the outset, this seems like a good idea to restart the Haitian economy and employ people, something that Haiti will need for the long term.
What is even more fascinating is the way they attempt to get the U.S.'s attention during a trade meeting, and how the U.S. representative really is calling the shots; there are lots of poor countries trying to export to the U.S.; it can pick and choose those who it will encourage trade with. According to the recorded part of the story, the Haitians are trying to utilize their current position as the devastated country constantly in the news in order to gain trade leverage. America has used trade as a political tool in the past (in fact, it is a very powerful political tool) in Egypt, Pakistan and even in an effort to quell Israel/Palestine conflict.

The last point the article made, about the pro-Haiti Charles Rangel's scandal and step down possibly hurting Haiti's economic development and recovery is an astonishing revelation of America's economic power in comparison to Haiti and other incredibly poor countries.

This radio story and its accompanying article have left me incredibly torn. I can certainly see the garment industry representative's point, that Haiti's future depends upon jobs and trade, and that lifted tariffs would give them a badly needed advantage. However, I wonder if garment manufacturing would simply take many Hatians from their current position of being desperately poor and jobless to being less poor and employed. Exporting more T shirts would certainly give the country something, but will it be enough for the country to build upon? Then again, there certainly aren't many other options.

Euro Bailout

Germany was reluctant to switch from the Deutschmark to the Euro, and now they are again reluctant to bailout the Greeks for fear it will set a standard that they will bailout the other countries hurting because of the financial crisis as well. Germanys Chancellor Angela Merkel has a tough decision ahead of her, because as the Economist states:

"A bail-out, Mrs Merkel fears, would break the bargain Germany struck in accepting the euro: that the single currency’s members would never jeopardise its stability nor ask Germans to pay for anyone else’s mismanagement. That said, the currency union was hardly an act of martyrdom by Germany. In the past decade its firms have modernised and their workers have accepted miserly pay rises, boosting their competitiveness".

This should leave Germany in a bind because their taxpayers, who have already put up "500 billion euro to shore up their own banks and billions more for companies". This means that Germans would be paying for for the comfort of the Greeks, and they seem to be reluctant to do so because,

"LESS than a year before the euro became the currency of 11 European countries in January 1999, a declaration signed by 155 German-speaking economists called for an “orderly”—ie, long—delay. The prospective euro members, they said, had not yet reduced their debt and deficits to suit a workable monetary union; some were using “creative accounting” to get there, and a casual attitude towards deficits would undermine confidence in the euro’s stability".

Germany is in dire straits compared to the rest of Europe in regards to the expectations surrounding it. Furthermore, Germany's actions in the next few years will heavily influence the structure of the political and economic policies in the European Union. Greece and the other countries will also determine the success of the partnerships as well. Some economists say that Germany can " can contribute to a longer-term solution by stimulating domestic consumption, which would help the Mediterranean miscreants grow out of their problems". However, as we discussed earlier in class, if Greece doesn't have comparative advantage in goods, then how can they grow out of their debt?

Do you think Germany should bailout Greece? How can the economic union in Europe be revolutionized? Do you see Greece as being able to grow out of its debt, or will it default? Should other nations in Europe in the Euro-zone combine money together in order to bail out Greece together rather than relying on one country such as Germany?

Tuesday, March 2, 2010

I know it's not my week, but...

I get e-mails a couple times a day from the NY Times with various news stories, and I thought I'd post one sent today since it goes along exactly with the "Super-fun" topic today in class.

http://www.nytimes.com/2010/03/03/nyregion/03gowanus.html?hp&emc=na

Genetically Modified Crops: Helpful Innovation or Science Gone Wrong?

In class today, we were introduced to a rather sinister corporation named Monsanto. Monsanto, in addition to selling herbicides, is a World leader in the market for Genetically Modified Crops. Even without Monsanto's tarnished name attached to them, Genetically Modified Crops have long been a source of controversy. Around the world, people are inherently afraid of such an "unnatural" idea as genetic modification of plants, with government policies in areas like Europe, where genetically modified foods are closely monitored and regulated, reflecting this fear.

Do Genetically Modified foods deserve their bad reputation? There are certainly legitimate concerns about them. Companies that produce a new type of Genetically modified crop are generally allowed to "patent" the gene. This means that farmers growing crops with the patented gene without the permission of the company holding the patent can be sued for "patent infringement". This is particularly controversial with crops like corn which are pollinated by wind, as patented genetically modified genes can end up in the crops of farmers not intending to grow the genetically modified crops in question. Another concern are the goals of the various genetic improvements. With Monsanto, for example, the primary advantage of its most popular type of genetically modified crop is the ability withstand more pesticides. And as pesticides are harmful for the environment and potentially detrimental to human health, encouraging the use of even more pesticides is a worrying prospect.

On the other hand, genetically modified foods hold great promise in areas like crop yield, pest resistance, and hardiness, while little evidence has emerged to suggest that genetically modified crops are less healthy than "normal" crops. Moreover, big, multinational corporations like Monsanto do not in any way have a monopoly on the development and production of genetically modified foods, with governments in countries like Brazil, China, and India engaged in research into genetically modified foods. Personally, I feel that with a more active role by government in the development of genetically modified foods, reforms regarding the patenting of genetically modified genes, and government imposed incentives against harmful pesticides, genetically modified foods have the potential to increase agricultural efficiency and productivity. What are your thoughts on the matter? Can genetically modified foods improve the food industry, or are they liable to cause more harm than good?

Walmart and Urban Areas: $100 and You're Feet are Still Wet

I’m opening with a quote from the ever observant Terry Pratchett in the fantasy book Men at Arms, which goes back to shoes again:

“The reason that the rich were so rich, Vimes reasoned, was because they managed to spend less money.

Take boots, for example. He earned thirty-eight dollars a month plus allowances. A really good pair of leather boots cost fifty dollars. But an affordable pair of boots, which were sort of OK for a season or two and then leaked like hell when the cardboard gave out, cost about ten dollars. Those were the kind of boots Vimes always bought, and wore until the soles were so thin that he could tell where he was in Ankh-Morpork on a foggy night by the feel of the cobbles.

But the thing was that good boots lasted for years and years. A man who could afford fifty dollars had a pair of boots that’d still be keeping his feet dry in ten years’ time, while a poor man who could only afford cheap boots would have spent a hundred dollars on boots in the same time and would still have wet feet.

This was the Captain Samuel Vimes ‘Boots’ theory of socio-economic unfairness.”


What does this have to do with Walmart moving in to a poor urban area of Chicago? There are plenty of people there who fit well within “Vimes ‘Boots’ theory of socio-economic unfairness.” The residents of the area have no other choice than to buy cheap goods that wear out quickly, people whose immediate needs trump sustainably or long term goals. Walmart is attempting to maintain its Monopoly by moving from a rural setting where they counted on many people wanting many disposable things to an urban area where people have no choice but to buy the least expensive, and often least durable option. And it will ultimately wind up like a cheap shoe for the community.

A University of Illinois, Chicago study of a Walmart that moved into a poor urban area looked at its impact on local businesses employment and government revenue, out to see whether or not a community welcoming Walmart is actually getting the employment and revenue the store promises. It found that:
"stores near Walmart were more likely to go out of business, eliminating the equivalent of about 300 full-time jobs -- about as many as Walmart initially added to the area."
Walmart essentially boosts jobs for the community initially, but then ultimately closes down the competition, making not change in job numbers. The community let in Walmart because it needed jobs immediately, but ultimately gained nothing in terms of employment. The head of the study states that:
"What we're seeing here is that placing a Walmart in an urban setting is basically a wash in terms of sales revenue for the city and jobs for local residents," Merriman said. "This means that communities around the city shouldn't see Walmart or other big-box retailers as a panacea for local economic problems"
Although the study points out that the retailers that were still in business after the introduction of Walmart retained their current wages and employment, 82 of the 306 businesses studied went out of business in the 8 spanning months. What the study doesn't mention are the wages and employment of the companies that did stay in business, it could be that they were paying lower prices already and that the 82 that went out of business paid more to their workers.
If Walmart is basically an employment shuffle, causing employment for some in the community and unemployment for others, could it be considered a downward shuffle. In the long run it may start costing the community, Walmart jobs pay poorly and have few options for advancement, the other business may eventually have to cut jobs or wages in order to compete, creating a poorer community as a whole which will be even more inclined to buy things at Walmart. The study is from 2008, I wonder what the neighborhood is like now.
The link is here

Apple Sues Phone Maker HTC Over Patents


Apple said on Tuesday that it had filed lawsuits against HTC, the Taiwan-based phone maker, accusing it of infringing on 20 Apple patents tied to the iPhone.

The suits, filed with the office of the United States International Trade Commission and the United States District Court in Delaware, say HTC violated patents covering the phone’s user interface, internal architecture and hardware.

HTC makes the Nexus One, a phone designed and sold by Google that runs Google’s Android operating system. Google was not mentioned in the suit, but the lawsuits are likely to worsen the already strained relations between Apple and Google.

Steven P. Jobs, Apple’s chief executive, said in a news release: “We can sit by and watch competitors steal our patented inventions, or we can do something about it. We’ve decided to do something about it.” Mr. Jobs added: “We think competition is healthy, but competitors should create their own original technology, not steal ours.”

HTC responded to the suit stating that, “HTC values patent rights and their enforcement but is also committed to defending its own technology innovations.” The company also said: “HTC only learned of Apple’s actions this morning via media reports, and therefore we have not yet had the opportunity to investigate the filings. Until we have had this opportunity, we are unable to comment on the validity of the claims being made against HTC.”

The legal documents from the suit, posted by the technology blog Gizmodo, cite patent infringement across numerous areas, including touch screens, power conservation and the orientation of graphics on a mobile phone.

According to the documents, Apple is asking the court to place an injunction against HTC that would bar them from “making, using, selling and/or offering” phones that impinge on the patents in questions, within the United States.

Cellphone makers have been playing catchup to the iPhone since it was introduced in June 2007, creating phones with similar touch-screen interfaces.

Apple has said that it has filed over 200 patents related to the iPhone.

Wal-mart's Green Revolution

Based on what we discussed in class today, Wal-Mart can deliver goods at a cheaper rate to consumers because of its efficiency in regards to cost cutting. The results of this practice are debatable. However, according to the Washington Post Wal-Mart is using this same strategy to pressure suppliers for the better through:

"Energy-saving details. Not just everyday low prices, but low greenhouse gas emissions".

As a result, suppliers like Lutex have had to add more efficient light bulbs, switch from Styrofoam to paper packaging, and add better ventilation to its factories. Wal-Mart has about 10,000 suppliers in China. If Wal-Mart was a country, it would be China's fifth- or sixth-largest export market. Basically, Wal-Mart is continuing it's dominance over its suppliers in becoming more green and environmentally friendly. Wal-Mart's 200 biggest suppliers in China have already cut down their energy use by about 5 percent because:

"pollution now threatens China's growth; as a result, awareness of climate change and energy security has spread in China. Likewise, as consumers grow more environmentally aware, Wal-Mart's executives have responded. On Thursday, the company pledged to cut 20 million metric tons of greenhouse gas emissions by 2015".

It is hard to view the controversial Wal-Mart we all know as a pusher for the environment. Based on what we have discussed in class about monopolies and also the video we viewed about Wal-Marts business practices in regards to Rubbermaid. Will Wal-Mart continue this shift in the business world from supplier to seller in terms of becoming friendly on the environment? As Wal-Mart chief executive Lee Scott states, "Meeting social and environmental standards is not optional. I firmly believe that a company that cheats on overtime and on the age of its labor, that dumps its scraps and its chemicals in our rivers, that does not pay its taxes or honor its contracts will ultimately cheat on the quality of its products. And cheating on the quality of products is the same as cheating on customers. We will not tolerate that at Wal-Mart".

It leads to the question about how business practices will continue in the future, and whether they will bear the responsibility of promoting good environmental practices and consumer habits as opposed to where governments have in the past. Wal-Mart seems to be serious about these changes and is seems to be using its power to lower its business costs and delivering the savings to the consumer, which may explain the reasoning for why it has continued to make profit in the recession. Therefore it leaves to question whether these practices are being used in order to lower costs, or to help the environment, or both?

This question is argued about by critics of Wal-Mart like , "China Labor Watch, a New York-based organization devoted to workers' rights in China, (who) said in a report last Thanksgiving that the case of Wal-Mart . . . shows that corporate codes of conduct and factory auditing alone are not enough to strengthen workers' rights if corporations are unwilling to pay the production costs associated with such codes". Critics such as this cause people to wonder about Wal-Mart's true intentions, as asked about on the worksheet from last class. This question also gets murkier when it comes to Wal-Mart's food policy because "Wal-Mart is trying to cultivate healthier farm techniques, with less pesticide, more organic fertilizer and more-efficient water use" through "buying directly from farmers and independent distributors, cutting out middlemen to save money for itself and boost the incomes of farmers" and also has established its own labels in China "to identify fruits from farms that meet its standards, although the standards are not up to U.S. organic levels".

Again, Wal-Mart is seen as trying to improve it's image, or is it just another way to cut it's cost to lower prices for the consumer. They also claim to raise the average Chinese farmer's income as well as buying local, which we previously discussed about in regards to Detroit and urban farming. Therefore, because Wal-Mart has the power to influence it's suppliers like this, does it, and other multi-national companies have a responsibility to the people as government's do, or are they simply out to make a quick buck by cutting costs or clever marketing to the trends of people?

Again, this brings up the long debated question discussed in class, does Wal-Mart benefit or hurt the consumer? How will these new regulations by Wal-Mart change the industry of the supplier side of businesses? If Wal-Mart continues to influence the economies of the USA and China, will international anti-monopoly laws need to be created, or will this benefit the economies of the USA and China together?

Monday, March 1, 2010

Money

In the "how to change the world class" we just watched this interview with Muhammed Yunus, who I'm sure many of us have heard of before since he won the Noble Peace Prize and such. But seriously, he's a cool guy, and I'd just like to spend a few minutes admiring him. He seems like the kind of guy who actually understands how to apply economic theory to real life. In his interview, he specifically said that his most influential teacher told him to remember that life is not based on theory but vice versa. So if a situation doesn't seem to fit with a certain theory the answer is reexamine the theory and adjust it. The article explains the basics of his most notable achievement, Grameen Bank, which has revolutionized micro loans:

The University welcomed Nobel Peace Prize winner, Dr. Muhammad Yunus, to Foellinger auditorium on Monday night.

Interim President Stanley Ikenberry presented him with the Presidential Medal, which is the highest honor the University can give.

He added that the opportunity to bring students in contact with Yunus was the best part of the event.“I thought students responded remarkably; there was an excitement in the room,” Ikenberry said.

Yunus is widely recognized for his creation of Grameen Bank in Bangladesh, which provided micro-loans to the poor. Micro-loans give small loans to those in poverty and are intended to spark entrepreneurship. The first micro-loan was $27 to a total of 41 villagers in Bangladesh.

“You need a dollar to catch a dollar,” he said.

Yunus said that prior to micro-loans, conventional banks in Bangladesh gave money to men and wealthy individuals.

So, he created this bank to give money to women and the poor.

Since the bank’s opening, Grameen Bank has awarded over $8 billion to rickshaw drivers, artisans and other people living in dire poverty.

He explained that the bank is unique because the borrowers own the bank themselves. He said that when banks make money, it goes back to the borrowers because they are the ones who are the shareholders.

He continued on and said that conventional banks require people’s past credit and business history, which is something that the poorest people do not have.

“We made it simple. We are not interested in your past, so you don’t have to tell us anything. We are interested in your future,” Yunus said.

He addressed the criticism that micro-loans can only work for entrepreneurs.

“I never could accept this argument because we started out with the poorest people,” he said.

He said the women he gave loans to at first were basket weavers who were too afraid to accept money.

These women told Yunus to give the money to their husbands.

“That’s not entrepreneurial behavior,” he added.

He said that businesses today are concerned with profit maximization. Businesses based on selflessness, or “social business”, does not really exist.

Yunus said that giving back to the community is also an exciting thing, and that’s what we should focus on.

Students who attended the program agreed with Yunus’s ideas, and said they took away their own thoughts about social business.

Mitchell Popadziuk, senior in LAS, said that before the presentation the idea of business benefiting people seemed like an oxymoron; however, now it seems possible.

“Literally while I was sitting there, I was thinking about way to create my own social business and other ways to promote this idea,” he said.

Roshan Murthy, freshman in Engineering, said he is taking a class about micro-finance right now, and social business is something he wants to become involved in.

“I’m an engineer, and I plan to do exactly what he said today,” he said.

I am so impressed by Yunus' creativity when it comes to dreaming up a system outside of the popularly accepted one. In his interview he said that when he was starting this project, he had a lot of trouble getting a bank to agree. Eventually they consented because he agreed to be the guarantor, so that if the poor person defaulted on the loan he would be the one paying it back to the bank (all the banks gave the same reason for not wanting to loan to the poor: nobody does it. you can't do it). After he got it working in one village, they still weren't convinced that it wasn't a fluke and would actually work anywhere. He spread it across and entire province, one specifically chosen because of its poverty, and still the bank was not impressed. Yunus built his own bank with specifically structured policies in response.

What I want to ask is, our economy is in the pits right now because of the guys in charge of the housing market decided to loan to poor people, people who previously were thought not to be able to afford loans. Yunus won a peace prize for doing the same thing. Why did his way work and not ours? What can we do to have the same kind of success he's had with Grameen Bank? Should we try or should we believe that the bank is right and it only works in certain areas?



Don't Worry About the Government

A man came into one of my classes today named Kenneth Mulder (or something close to that) who has lived the most fascinating life. He originally went to West Point for reasons he didn't share, but upon realizing that they were trying to teach him to kill people, that our military is more offensive than defensive, he dropped out. Ken then came to Kalamazoo because it was the only school to which he was accepted that hadn't started yet.
He is now a teacher at Green Mountain College in Vermont, and inbetween has been all over from Western Europe to jail. hmmm. But one of the economically intriguing thing he talked about is that he doesn't pay taxes. Now, my mother always told me that the only certain things in life are death and taxes so I was shocked by this. But here is his situation:
In further efforts to not comply with the army's policy of killing (Ken is now a quaker, always a peacemaker) Ken decided he didn't want to pay taxes to the federal government because they support the army. He says that there are two usual ways of going about this. One, is to pay all your taxes except the portion that would fund the army and write the IRS a not explaining that you instead donated that money to some sort of charity. Apparently the Internal Revenue Service is not overly fond of people who do this and sometimes takes their house. Ken thought this sounded like a bummer of a plan, so he chose option B: make so little money you aren't required to pay taxes. "So little money" was at that time defined as less than $6,600. Oh yeah. He was voluntarily paid well below his actual earning just to stick it to the man. He now is married with four children and claims that you are allowed to make a lot more when you have four kids. I'm sure this is true but I'm doubting that amounts to much of an extravagant living. He is the antichrist of economic growth, but is he not perhaps a model for the economic future? People living simply and sustainably rather than with an infinite appetite for consumption? I wonder what it would be like to budget on that kind of money, and how many of us could handle it?

State Proposes Closing 55 Parks and Historic Sites

Facing historic financial pressures, New York State has identified 41 state parks that it plans to close, along with 14 historic sites, and late last week it began notifying people who had secured campsites in 12 of the parks that their reservations were being canceled.

The move to refund campers’ reservation fees was perhaps the strongest sign that the State Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation was not engaging in budgetary brinksmanship in announcing last month that it would shutter nearly a quarter of the state parks and almost half of its historic sites. The agency’s proposed closings, along with a spate of service reductions, followed Gov. David A.’s $20 million cut to the parks budget.

“It’s the first time ever that parks will have closed in New York State due to budget constraints,” said Robin Dropkin, executive director of Parks and Trails New York, an advocacy group based in Albany. “Even during the Great Depression parks remained open. They’re sending back reservation money, so that’s a pretty good sign that they’re not crying wolf.”

The proposed closings are spread around the state, from Long Island, where six parks, including Orient Beach and Cold Spring Harbor State Park, are on the target list, to the Thousand Islands region, where another six are identified. In addition, there are numerous planned service cuts: At Riverbank State Park in Manhattan, operating hours would be reduced and one of two pools would not open this summer. Among the historic sites slated to close is Philipse Manor Hall, a Revolution-era site in Yonkers.

It was unclear whether the public would still have access to some of the parks if they closed. Eileen Larrabee, a spokeswoman for the parks agency, said closing parks meant that the state would simply stop spending on them, for upkeep, security and the like. Safety concerns could prompt officials to close gates or post “keep out” signs.

“We’re in the process of going to each of our facilities and determining what a park closure is going to mean,” she said.

The agency has already absorbed significant cuts in the last three years and during the peak summer months has a skeletal staff in place inside the state parks. “It’s not an agency that’s been dripping with dollars,” Ms. Dropkin said. “They were pretty lean to begin with. They do their best, but the infrastructure is really crumbling. They keep the bathroom doors together with duct tape.”

Ms. Larrabee said the selection of parks to be closed was based on revenue, operating costs and number of visitors. The dozen parks for which camping reservation fees are being refunded by the parks department offer a total of 450 campsites. By contrast, the entire system has 8,355 campsites. But interest in camping usually rises during economic recessions, as families look for cheaper vacation alternatives.

“I’m disappointed to see that they are taking steps so final as to cancel campsite reservations,” said Gary S. DeYoung, director of tourism at the 1000 Islands International Tourism Council. “I thought it was like anything else in the budget right now — that it was the governor’s proposal and until the Legislature weighed in, it wasn’t final.”

The Onion is funny

I know it's not my blog week, but I felt like I should share this because it's amazing.